Stranger Than Heaven

Stranger Than Heaven’s Combat Left Me Cold, But I Want to See More

Combat is probably the aspect I care the least about in Stranger Than Heaven. Obviously, yes, it’s an essential part of the game, but I’m much more interested in its narrative, adventure elements, and even the music. And when all those aspects seem so strong, it seems strange to theme an entire demo around combat alone, and as much as I hate to say it, I don’t love that combat.

The Yakuza games have always been known for their fast and frenetic combat, not counting, of course, the series’ transition to turn-based RPGs. But Stranger Than Heaven is taking a drastically, deliberately different approach — trying to mesh the crunchiness and brutality of Yakuza with the more methodical intention of something like a Soulslike. I want to be very clear that this game is not a Soulslike in any fashion, but there are certainly similarities in the combat, particularly in how it emphasizes positioning and a sort of mechanical rhythm.

Stranger Than Heaven

If you’ve seen any of the trailers for Stranger Than Heaven, you might have seen the game’s unique combat setup, where you independently use both sides of the main character, Makoto’s, body. Essentially, the left bumper and trigger are assigned to the left side of the body, and the right bumper and trigger to the right side. This means if you hit L1, you’ll do a left punch, and R1, a right punch. L2 and R2 do slower but more damaging attacks, and any attack can be charged up by holding the button. You can combo these four buttons in any order you want, and the contextual options this opens up is really important. For example, an enemy might grab your right arm, so you need to use your left to free yourself.

Then, you also have dodge, block, and parry, which also have directional contexts — if an enemy swings their sword from the left, you need to block and parry to the left. On top of all this, you have different weapon styles that give you distinct attacks. There will be more than ten weapons in the full game, but for the demo, I only had bare fists, a knife, and a crowbar.

While complicated, it sounds like a good idea on paper, but in practice, I left feeling quite mixed. On the one hand, the combat allows a good degree of freedom in how you build your combos. At the same time, it does manage to evoke the same bone-crunching feel that Yakuza is so good at — blows feel like they have real weight behind them.

Stranger Than Heaven P1

But on the other hand, at least from what I played, I think the combat moves at a far too sluggish pace and are often imprecise. I played through three battles across three of the game’s eras: the first against a group of basic enemies, the second against a group and a big brute-type, and the third against a deadly single swordsman.

The group battles were by far the most enjoyable, with my wild swings sometimes catching multiple enemies, or Makoto seamlessly picking up a bottle to bash an enemy over the head. You can tell there’s a learning curve, but a few small issues quickly started cropping up. Enemies have far too much health, making these battles drag on.

Admittedly, I don’t know if that’s something that can be affected by gear, stats, etc. But once you start taking on specialized enemies, especially the boss, it quickly becomes a game of simply dodging or parrying. If you time your parry or dodge right, you get a chance to counterrack, and I quickly realized this was the only viable option for beating him. But he also had an incredibly damaging special that was nearly a one-hit kill, and looks incredibly similar to another attack.

So telegraphing seems like it could be a problem. And finally, I think the crowbar feels unequivocally awful to use in every way. It’s slow and imprecise, doesn’t do the damage you expect, and enemies absolutely mauled me whenever I used it.

Stranger Than Heaven P3

Stranger Than Heaven obviously has a long way to go before release, and I’m sure a lot can be ironed out and refined. But I’m a bit worried about how the actual concept and basis of combat work in general. I don’t love how slow everything feels, and that overall reliance on parrying. I genuinely hope there’s a lot more depth to combat, and with additional weapons and music systems that we’ve seen in trailers, it seems like there could be.

I’m willing to give a little bit of the benefit of the doubt right now, but I really wanted Stranger Than Paradise to wow me — and it didn’t. And unfortunately, I can’t tell you literally anything else about the game, because I didn’t see anything beyond some of the aesthetic and thematic trappings of the areas.

Stranger Than Heaven P4

A lot of what Sega has shown off for Stranger Than Heaven has genuinely killed my enthusiasm for the game. Being a Yakuza prequel about the founding of the Tojo Clan feels unnecessarily constraining. The announcement of the game featuring Tupac as a character feels like genuinely grotesque digital necromancy. And now the combat has also left me cold.

There are elements I love about Stranger Than Heaven: the gorgeous visuals, the use of historical time periods, and the music, which seems genuinely incredible so far. But those worries are piling up quickly, and Ryu Ga Gotoku is going to have to win me back.