MLB The Show 25

MLB The Show 25 Review — Take Me Out to the Ball Game

A Home Run

Spring is in the air, and I can play the next iteration of MLB The Show from San Deigo Studio. From the opening menu, hearing the menu music that is so familiar reminds me that it’s Baseball season. I have played every release of MLB The Show since 2006, when David Ortiz was on the cover. Year after year, San Deigo Studio puts out what can safely be called one of the best sports sims of its kind. It’s easy to say it’s the best Baseball game because MLB The Show has little competition in this space.

The last couple of years, though, the series struggled to make fans of the series happy, and while they were innovative about change in gameplay, one of the core modes is Diamond Dynasty. They changed the formula for playing it in the previous two entries. Making a yearly game can tax the development team, and I understand they want to try new things. The good news for fans of the franchise is that they have continued to innovate on gameplay, but it went back to what the fans had been asking for regarding Diamond Dynasty.

Welcome To MLB The Show 25

With MLB The Show 25 being only next-gen, I was expecting a big difference with graphics, and I wasn’t disappointed, except for one feature. The attention to detail for each player model and facial expression is the best we have seen from the franchise. You sometimes can be fooled into thinking you’re watching a broadcast of an MLB game until you look a little closer at the stadiums. I don’t know what it is, but in any stadium with a water feature, and there are many, the water looks terrible. It can sometimes be distracting, and it’s been an issue for years.

Kauffman Stadium in Kansas City has a water feature in center field, but it looks more like a sheet of aluminum on a roller when you play the game. When I’m playing the game, and I have the option of not choosing a stadium that has a water feature, I do. Other ballparks, like Rogers Centre, where my hometown Toronto Blue Jays play, look fantastic, and the sights and sounds bring the stadium to life. If you turn on the instant reply, you can see the details the players and stadiums have in MLB The Show 25.

MLB The Show

MLB The Show 25 has added many more visuals to the game’s presentation, making it feel like the transition between plays in a live baseball game. Each home team has a theme for their broadcasts, incorporating team colours, making each game feel unique depending on the ballpark you’re playing in. When using franchise or exhibition modes, you can use the retro graphic theme we have seen in storylines and moments from the 1960s until 2009. It allows you to relive different ears of the game if you want to replay historical broadcasts like when the Blue Jays won the World Series in 1993. You won’t be able to play with all of the players from back then, but you can make the game’s presentation feel like back then with some available legends.

MLB The Show

The sound design is second to none, and I feel they have stepped up their game in some areas but still need to improve in others. We have more sounds from the game and different bat sounds that weren’t in previous versions. You can hear the ball hit off the bat differently, and from the sound, you only know what type of contact your bat has made with the ball. They had added more player heckling from the fans, and when playing as Derek Jeter at Citi Field, you can hear Mets Fans taunt him, but when playing at Yankee Stadium, you hear them chant “Derek Jeter.” MLB The Show 25 wants you to have the same experience you would have watching the game or being at the ballpark while playing the game. I wish they would get some updated anecdotes about players. Some announcers’ stories have been in the game for several years.

Because of the gameplay overhaul MLB The Show 24 saw, the gameplay in MLB The Show 25 wasn’t changed much, but they did introduce Ambush Hitting. Ambush Hitting is when you use the right thumb stick to guess which side of the plate the pitcher will throw the ball. If you guess correctly,  your PCI will be higher, making it easier to hit the ball, but if you guess incorrectly, it will be lower, making it more challenging to hit. I wasn’t a fan because it added one more thing I needed to do to hit the ball, but I knew that once I got used to it, I would become a better hitter.

MLB The Show has always had authentic hitting, and I know the team at San Deigo Studio has added this to give people that extra edge. You would have an advantage if it were real baseball and you anticipated where the pitch would be thrown. They didn’t deliver significant overhauls this year to the gameplay, but I was okay with it because I’m still getting used to PCI changes from last year.

MLB The Show

The fundamental changes come in game modes this year. Storylines that first got introduced in MLB The Show 22 are back and we get season three of the Negro Leagues. Hopefully, like last year, we will also get some legendary storylines, but they haven’t been announced yet. The storyline is some of my favourite content in the MLB The Show because you get to relive history and learn about baseball as the player. Graphically, they take you back, and the gameplay looks historically accurate, from the dirt on the mound to the cleats on your feet. Road to the Show had a massive overhaul this year, letting you start your high school career and test it out before playing in college to improve your pro before entering the minors. By the time your created player gets to the major, he has better attributes, making it a more enjoyable experience when you play the game.

MLB The Show

Diamond Dynasty got a whole new revamp, and fans should be rejoicing. Gone are sets and seasons, and back is the grind to 99. For the last two versions of MLB The Show, the team at San Diego Studio has been making the game feel more like pay to win instead of rewarding you for playing. Many sports games make you pay for a lot of content, but MLB The Show has always made the content obtainable in the past. If you wanted to pay for it, you could.

In MLB The Show 22, and 23 the sets and seasons felt more like everything was behind a pay wall and it sucked the enjoyment out of the game mode. All cards you unlock are back to being available in earnable packs and through the programs and additional programs. Team Afinity allows you to earn rewards towards your favourite team now and now just each division and rewards you for the whole season. I always loved building an ultimate Toronto Blue Jays team, and now I can and will always earn rewards for doing so. Each team has their program in the Team Affinity mode inside Diamond Dynasty, and it’s a welcomed change.

MLB The Show

This year, they added a new rogulike mode to Diamond Dynasty called Diamond Quest. It looks like a broad game, with you rolling a dice to get across the screen and earn rewards. If you lose any events, you will get disadvantaged in your next match and earn lesser rewards. If you win your events along the way, you will get boosts you can use, like more velocity on pitches or a higher chance of hitting home runs in your next match. These advantages and disadvantages can only be used in Diamond Quest. Again, game modes like March to October, Mini Season, and Conquest are still there, so you can earn XP towards the program along with earning special rewards in those game modes, like unique cards of some of baseball’s biggest legends from the past. My favourite player of all time, Jose Bautista, is one the first legnds you can earn in the game, and it was a welcome sight for me to see him in the game. Other notable legends you can use in the diamond dynasty this year are Manny Ramirez, Roger Clemens, James “Cool Papa” Bell, Jason Kipnin, Lance Berkman, Bobby Abreu, Jason Varitek, and Clay Buchholz.

MLB The Show

Verdict

Year in and year out, the team at San Deigo Studio could easily not change things and do a re-skin from the previous game because they don’t have a lot of competition. I’m happy that isn’t the case because they listened to their community, improved upon the suggestions, and made the game far more enjoyable. I was losing interest in the series because I felt they were going down the path of microtransactions instead of rewarding the community.

MLB The Show was the only game I used to put money into after the initial purchase in years past because I felt they deserved my money, but in the last couple of years, they lost their way. I’m so happy they have changed all that and made one of the best games in years. Out of all the prominent sports titles this year, I have to say this game is by far the best you can buy right now. It rewards the players for playing, honours the game of baseball, and makes you feel like you’re part of the game. Do you want to know what all of us fans want in a sports game? MLB The Show 25 is it.

Recommended

[The publisher provided a copy of the game for review purposes.]

Reviewed on: PlayStation 5

 

MLB The Show 25
MLB The Show 25 Review — Take Me Out to the Ball Game
Summary
MLB The Show 25 offers baseball fans the chance to relive the history of the game and honour its new traditions.
Liked
Diamond Dynasty is no longer pay to win
Improved Ambush Hitting
Franchise Mode rewards you for playing
Graphics overhaul on player animations
Cross progression
Didn't Like
Announcers are using old commetary
Really bad water effects in the ball parks
9